We're the #1 Pool Safety Barrier Provider in the U.S.

Pool Cover vs Fence

When it comes to ensuring the safety of your swimming pool area, the debate between two prominent choices is centered around pool covers and gates. Evaluating pool cover vs fence pros and cons is vital for making an informed decision that balances safety, convenience, and costs for your specific needs.

Both options offer unique benefits, but which one is the right choice for your needs? Below, you’ll learn all about safety fence vs pool cover!

Pool Cover vs Fence

Pool covers are innovative elements designed to cover the surface of your swimming pool. They come in various types, aesthetics, and materials to fit your needs and budget. From solar covers to automatic components, each model offers unique benefits for debris protection, heat retention, and adding a layer of safety.

Pool fences, on the other hand, are physical barriers installed around the perimeter of your swimming pool. Typically, these elements are crafted with durable materials able to withstand even the harshest conditions and prevent unauthorized access, enhancing safety, reliability, and convenience.

At Pool Guards, you can find various types of removable pool safety fences that combine materials with advanced safety features, ensuring peace of mind without compromising style. You can explore our various products and find the perfect blend of security and aesthetic appeal for your pool area and taste!

Pool Cover vs Fence
Source: shutterstock.com / Photo Contributor: Sauce Reques

Design and effectiveness

Pool covers are made from special, durable materials, such as UV-stabilized polyethylene, polypropylene, or vinyl. These materials are designed to withstand various weather conditions, ensuring the cover’s integrity and reliability. They can contribute to safety by preventing accidental falls while protecting your pool from debris, reducing evaporation, and maintaining water temperature.

Pool fences, conversely, are crafted from intricate weaves of thin metal or plastic fibers, creating a screen-like mesh effect surrounding your pool area. This mesh gives the pool fences strength and integrity, providing a physical barrier that’s always in place and preventing accidents around your pool. Amongst the numerous types available, mesh pool fences stand out as a stronger and safer option.

Installation complexity

Pool covers, especially removable or manual pool types, can be relatively easy to install. This involves spreading the cover over the pool surface and securing it with weights or fasteners. However, employing an automatic pool cover vs fence may require professional installation that might be costly.

In contrast, pool fences are straightforward components requiring more installation time yet minimal effort. Whether you opt for removable pool gate options or aluminum, steel, glass, or vinyl ones, you can easily install them with basic tools and a detailed installation guide.

Maintenance requirements

Maintenance requirements and longevity differ between pool covers and fences. Pool covers serve as frontline defenders against debris and potential contaminants.

They are designed with a focus on endurance. While they ensure your pool remains a safe environment, they need regular cleaning, frequent checkups for functionality, and maintenance requirements.

On the other hand, pool fences, especially those crafted from durable materials like mesh or aluminum, are extremely durable. They ensure a robust safety barrier around your pool area.

Whether rain or direct light, they can withstand even the harshest conditions. They require less frequent maintenance, mainly occasional checkups, and repairs to latches and gates.


When it comes to convenience, both pool covers and safety fences are remarkable components yet offer different advantages. Pool covers, for instance, are relatively easy to place and remove, especially automatic versions, which simplify the process even further with the push of a button.

They also prevent debris from entering the pool while retaining heat, contributing to both cleanliness and energy efficiency. This offers excellent convenience for owners.

On the contrary, while pool fences may require more involvement in the initial installation, they offer long-term convenience by requiring minimal effort. Once installed, you will have a barrier that provides continuous safety and protection without needing regular adjustment, making them a more practical and convenient option.

Cost considerations

We understand that cost is a significant factor when deciding between a pool cover and a safety fence. However, the prices can greatly vary depending on the materials used, the size of the pool area, and additional features like automation or other elements.

Our standard pool covers are priced at $352.97 – $525.00, providing a comprehensive solution for maintaining pool safety and cleanliness. They contain our patented mesh material blend, which ensures added strength, sustainability, and shading protection.

Conversely, our pool fences are available in standard 15-foot sections at $89.85- $97.35. They’re premium interlocking pool safety mesh with a border crafted from high-quality materials, ensuring long-lasting safety and compliance with local regulations. By offering continuous protection without requiring frequent adjustments, they provide a practical and cost-effective choice.

Cost Considerations
Source: shutterstock.com / Photo Contributor: Cmspic

Regulatory compliance

Compliance with regulatory requirements is critical when considering pool safety options. Regardless of the type you choose, the pool safety feature must comply with local safety standards.

As different states have slightly different rules and regulations, you must check your area’s height limitations and ground, vertical, and horizontal spacing requirements for pool fencing. For pool covers, you must check whether you need a permit to install a pool enclosure, specific safety standards, and urban planning rules.

Failing to comply with the regulatory requirements might result in serious consequences, including increased risk of accidents, legal penalties, or mandatory corrective actions. That said, it’s important to ensure complete adherence to avoid financial repercussions and maintain proper safety around your swimming area.


Understanding the key differences between pool cover vs fence is critical to making an informed decision that enhances security and aligns with your lifestyle and local regulations. While both options offer valuable convenience and safety benefits, it’s important to consider their specific limitations and maintenance capabilities before deciding what best fits your needs.

Ultimately, the goal is to enhance the protection and enjoyment of your swimming pool for everyone involved. Order your safety element today and put an end to your safety worries!

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Stay up to date on everything about Pool Guard USA.

Contact Dealer

Please fill out the form below with your information. Your local dealer will be notified about your inquiry.